WPCt ,!7`}ⴛvQp8Mx{9ŢS`qGhMKu<Pm:/7enjgc'v8T:ٙ]+WۄxKGkV$CvXU-#z9=.,8c53\r6t"NFEe֓+Sv&41 NlZ HЯ& X+(śbߓf{f^ytD^N+rر(EŽ|nOFBeӘlkA~ {!]yxIaW+w?j)ŋ5RU/{7z()S-?rsYM8`~:heEU jP3ޯPv_*ttyɨPJxsp|OfdnM_uًb!1w/)sgoSS>9[C&-UNv % 0:# iUNw  ^ N 0~Z 0D   f a   m  N w| 4 / UN>    ((( 0000 BHHHH eeeekkbl(9 Z6Times New Roman RegularX($USUS.,HP LaserJet 3150,,,,0C:\DOCUME~1\USDC\APPLIC~1\Corel\PERFEC~1\11\CUSTOM~1\NUFFER~2\CAPTIO~1.WPTC:\Documents and Settings\USDC\Application Data\Corel\PerfectExpert\11\Custom WP Templates\ Nuffer Templates WP11\Caption - Nuffer.wpt(9 Z 6Times New Roman Regular   ($USUS.,    1    _ ` Docketno.55.&0 (.(3($ !USUS.,      1  (%$  1    ($USUS.,    2    _ ` Docketno60,filedDecember12,2003.TABLE A12U  ($USUS.,    3    _ ` Docketno59,filedDecember12,2003.EEUUEEEE/:i+003|x(9 Z6Times New Roman Regular  ($USUS.,    4    _ ` Fed.R.Civ.P.37(a)(4).34starthere dH- - !USUS.,  _X$XXX,% '   8dXXd8@< < INTHEUNITEDSTATESDISTRICTCOURT    FORTHEDISTRICTOFUTAH   Ѐ  *#ddd Xdd Xdd X(#(#,<dd ,<dd +     %  %_#X$XXX$=#JOHN_LYTHGOE_,  X$XXX$    l  Plaintiff(s),    l vs.   %  %p#X$XXX$#_ROBINTINO_S,INC.,aUtahX$XXX$Ԁcorporation, |t  etal. h`   l  Defendant(s). @8  ',$ '%  ORDERREGARDING   ATTORNEYSFEES%   CaseNo:#X$XXX$#1:02CV0167DB   %  DistrictJudge%|ԀDeeV.Benson h`  MagistrateJudgeDavidNuffer @8 (,$  (  %    PlaintiffsMotiontoCompelwasresolvedinahearingDecember1,2003,andanorder 4, filedDecember8,2003.  %  1      ׀TheorderrequiredthatPlaintiffsandDefendants'counselfile    AffidavitsofAttorneysFeesandExpensestotheCourtonorbeforeDecember12,2003,andany " responsestotheAffidavitsonorbeforeDecember19,2003.KaraBartonfiledanaffidavit |  %  2      ׀and $ Kathleen_Toth_Ԁfiledacertificateofserviceofheraffidavit,0  %  3      ׀deliveringacopyoftheaffidavitto & chambers.Noresponseswerefiled. l!d(   Thepapersfiledonthismotionandthediscussionsatthehearingrevealthatinlarge D#<* measurethemotiontocompelwasnecessitatedbyeachpartysinabilityorunwillingnessto %, speakwitheachother.Whilethereweresomegenuinedisputes,thelackofdirect,inperson &. communicationexacerbatedthesituation._Robintino_sincurredX$XXX$atotalof31.5attorneyhours (!0 totaling$4,115#X$XXX$ #.00andthemovingparty,_Lythgoe_,incurred30hourstotaling$5,850.00.These  amountswouldhavebeenreduceddramaticallyifcommunicationbetweencounselhadbeen  openandmostofthediscoverydisputeshadbeenresolvedwithoutamotion.However,in   recognitionthatsomeoftheDefendantsfailurestoprovidediscoverywerenotsubstantially   justified,  %  4      ׀ h`   ITISHEREBYORDEREDthatDefendantsshallpaytoPlaintiffthesumof$1,000.00 @8  forreasonableexpenses,includingattorney;ssfees,incfeurredinmakingthemotion.     ITISFURTHERORDEREDthatKathleen_Toth_Ԁshallfileaheroriginalaffidaibvitwiththe   courtifithasnotalerereadybeenfiled.itwvtofco    * January6,2004!  .    BYTHECOURT: xp _____________________________ (  DavidNuffer   U.S.MagistrateJudge