WPCw> AXړB3(BCͪqy N(-[1BhW91nT^Lt\TkOmSxż=w9j*>ڕԭ7kK`X^OoƅA3#fVJ7U?p]pmÖ8pkOt#4eVgZ)c&?uцʠ\l4A3/Mإ,wMM #^] 20VybQ*!%{t+Mo#,sڿAkǭߥFeG#NCVE) b<:j}V16V 80'8B':#zy "f3?L#z.6l_jjX /AP׌|;۲͝h\,(e'Yqbj3(jPǢmmOsLgnJbxdUNx % 0:#  k UNy w ^ 4    f a   m 0~ NX 0DZ  0U 0 0 0 C 0K 0  0 | 0 B+ 0H 0 0  0 08e 0b 0 06 0 0f 0 0 0 03 0 0! 0" 0" 0I# 0# 0$ 0C% 0>& 0?& 07' 0( 0( 0) 0* 0+ 0[, 02-- 0_- 0:[. 0Y. 0_. 0 M/ 0W0 01 B*3 D/ 4 D+84 0c4 D/i6 06 06f7 07 0:8 0^8 0<<9 1ex9U69U>:U*Q: 1u{: 72: 0c";;<B==(9 Z6Times New Roman RegularX($USUS.,HP LaserJet 3150,,,,0C:\DOCUME~1\USDC\APPLIC~1\Corel\PERFEC~1\11\CUSTOM~1\NUFFER~2\CAPTIO~1.WPTC:\Documents and Settings\USDC\Application Data\Corel\PerfectExpert\11\Custom WP Templates\ Nuffer Templates WP11\Caption - Nuffer.wpt(9 Z 6Times New Roman RegularA&0 /:i+003|x ($USUS.,    1    _ ` Docketno.39,filedOctober20,2003.TABLE A12U(.(3($ !USUS.,      0  (#$  0    ($USUS.,    2    _ ` SchedulingOrder,docketno.6,filedJanuary8,2003,andSecondAmended  SchedulingOrder,docketno.19,filedJuly2,2003.  ($USUS.,    3    _ ` SeePlaintiffsX5`XXXThirdSetofRequestsforProductionofDocuments#X5`XXX5`#Ԁattachedas  ExhibitAtoPlaintiffsMemoranduminSupportofPlaintiffsMotiontoCompelDiscoveryand  RecoverAttorneyFees,docketno.40,filedOctober10,2003.*+ (_2623  ..*G+G (_25   /%` ` hp x /23  ../%` ` hp x /   *8+8 (_24  ," hp x ,23  ..," hp x ,  *5+5 (_23 ` ) hp x )23  ..) hp x ) ` 4*2+2 (_22  &hhp x &23  ..&hhp x &  */+/ (_21  #p x #23  ..#p x #  starthere*,+, (_20 h  p x 23  .. p x h 5*)+) (_19  pp x 23  ..pp x    d*&+& (_18   x 23  .. x   *AA (_17  5+ ` hp x 523  Ԁ5+ ` hp x 5  *GG (_16   /%` ` hp x /23  Ԁ/%` ` hp x /   H*88 (_15  ," hp x ,23  Ԁ," hp x ,  *55 (_14 ` ) hp x )23  Ԁ) hp x ) ` *22 (_13  &hhp x &23  Ԁ&hhp x &  - -*// (_12  #p x #23  Ԁ#p x #  *,, (_11 h  p x 23  Ԁ p x h *)) (_10  pp x 23  Ԁpp x   (&& &_9   x 23  Ԁ x   (AA &_8  5+ ` hp x 523  5+ ` hp x 5  (GG &_7   /%` ` hp x /23  /%` ` hp x /   (88 &_6  ," hp x ,23  ," hp x ,  (55 &_5 ` ) hp x )23  ) hp x ) ` (22 &_4  &hhp x &23  &hhp x &  (// &_3  #p x #23  #p x #  (,, &_2 h  p x 23   p x h ()) &_1  pp x 23  pp x   &&& $_   x 23   x   0AA.Normal  5+ ` hp x 55+ ` hp x 5  <AA:Definition T  5+ ` hp x 55+ ` hp x 5  <AA:Definition L , 5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 586Definition(hh&H1  5+ ` hp x 5      5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H2  5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H3  5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H4  5+ ` hp x 5 XXX 5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H5  5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 5  (]]&H6  5+ ` hp x 5  5+ ` hp x 5  2DD0Address  5+ ` hp x 55+ ` hp x 5  8MM6Blockquote , , 5+ ` hp x 5   5+ ` hp x 5,*CITE,dl*CODEKZ<6X9`(Courier NewKS[\  `&Times New RomanS42Emphasis64Hyperlink    <:FollowedHype    4go2Keyboard KZ<6X9`(Courier NewKS[\  `&Times New RomanS <:Preformatted  /%  ,Kk %#/KZ<6X9`(Courier NewKS[\  `&Times New RomanS/%  ,Kk %#/  <:zBottom of 7O(X7    5+ ` hp x 5?\%2A`Arial?  S[\  `&Times New RomanS7P(X75+ ` hp x 5  &  d dN)1dxd'dxd<:zTop of For7R(X7    5+ ` hp x 5?\%2A`Arial?  S[\  `&Times New RomanS7P(X75+ ` hp x 5  N)2dxd0KS.SampleKZ<6X9`(Courier NewKS[\  `&Times New RomanS0.Strong 8dl6TypewriterKZ<6X9`(Courier NewKS[\  `&Times New RomanS42Variable: 8HTML MarkupB      2 0CommentB  %&()+-./ 35;AGMSY_11.1.1.1.1.1.1.1.<6X9`(Courier New\  `&Times New Roman%2A`Arial3#37=CIQYag1.a.i.(1)(a)(i)1)a)]i)(;3$2#  0  .3  0    ($USUS.,    4    _ ` Defendants[sic]MemoranduminOppositiontoPlaintiffsMotiontoCompel  Discovery,docketno.44,filedOctober20,2003,pages34. ($USUS.,    7    _ ` Docketno.39,filedOctober20,2003. ($USUS.,    5    _ ` Id.at4. ($USUS.,    6    _ ` Rule26(b)(1),Fed.R.Civ.P.(Emphasisadded). !USUS.,  _X5`XXX,% '   8dXXd8@< < INTHEUNITEDSTATESDISTRICTCOURT    FORTHEDISTRICTOFUTAHNORTHERNDIVISION   Ѐ  *#ddd Xdd Xdd X(#(#,<dd ,<dd +     %  JEFFP.HYDE,%q    l  Plaintiff,    l vs.   %  _BOGNER_ԀOFAMERICA,INC.,% |t   l  Defendant. TL   '@8 ' ORDERGRANTING   MOTIONTOCOMPEL    CaseNo:% ! 1:02CV163TS%!7   %  DistrictJudge%yԀTedStewart |t  MagistrateJudgeDavidNuffer TL  (@8  (  %    PlaintiffmovedtocompelproductionofdocumentsresponsivetohisThirdSetof H@ RequestsforProductionofDocuments.  #  1      ׀Motionsforpartialsummaryjudgmentarependingand   thecaseissetfortrialinDecember.| #  2      ׀Thecaseisadisputeovercommissionsowingunderan   agreementthatprovidesforpaymentofcommissionsonsalesgeneratedbyPlaintiffHydeasa " salesrepresentativeforDefendant_Bogner_#X5`XXX5`=#ԀbutconsummatedwithinayearafterHydes $ termination.  x&   Hydepropoundeddiscoveryaskingfordocumentsrelatingtoallsalesconsummatedin X"P( theyearafterthearguableterminationdate. #  3      ׀_Bogner_Ԁstatesthatsincetheagreementonlypertains 0$(* tosalesgeneratedbyHyde,that_Bogner_Ԁneedonlyproduce documentswhichreflectsalesof &, _productgeneratedbyMr.Hyde.` #  4      ׀_Bogner_Ԁadmitsitproducednodocumentspertainingtothe  yearafterHydestermination becauseMr.Hydehadabsolutelynothingtodowithgenerating  thosesales....Accordingly,documentsrelatingtosuchsalesarenotrelevanttoanyissueinthis   litigation.bh #  5      ׀     _Bogner_Ԁmayberightabouttheultimateissueofrelevance.If_Bogner_Ԁwerearguing h` admissibilityofdocumentsattrial,itwouldlikelybeabletoexcludedocumentsofsalesin2002 @8  whichMr.Hydehadabsolutelynothingtodowith.Butthisisdiscovery,nottrial.Relevance   isnottheboundaryofdiscovery.Hydeisentitledtodiscover anymatter,notprivileged,thatis   relevanttotheclaimordefenseofanyparty...Relevantinformationneednotbeadmissibleat  thetrialifthediscoveryappearsreasonablycalculatedtoleadtothediscoveryofadmissible  evidence.c #  6      ׀Itishardtoimagineanydocumentsmorereasonablycalculatedtoleadtothe xp discoveryofadmissibleevidencethanrecordsofallsalesintheperiodforwhichHydeclaims PH potentialentitlementtocommissions.Forthatreason,itishardtoimagineanyjustificationfor (  thecavalierattitudeof_Bogner_Ԁindecliningthediscovery.Thatattitudeisrevealedinthefactual  historyrecitedinPlaintiffsmemorandumshowing_Bogner_sdelayeddisclosureofitsintenttobe   nonresponsive,andintherelativelycursorymemorandum_Bogner_Ԁfiled,withoutanyanalysisof " theapplicationoftheFederalRulesofCivilProcedureorcaselaw.XX5`Ԁ#X5`X#Theapparentdelay,as $  deadlinesapproach,istroubling. `&X"   Relevancewastheonlyobjectionstatedby_Bogner_,andthatobjectionisinvalid._Bogner_  mighthavestatedotherobjectionsbutdidnot.Giventheshorttimeframesremaininginthis  case,and_Bogner_sconduct,anyotherobjectionsarewaived.      `     h   ORDER  h` C  ITISHEREBYORDEREDthatthemotiontocompela #  7      ׀isGRANTED. @8    ITISFURTHERORDEREDthatPlaintiffisawardedhisreasonableexpensesincurred   inmakingthismotion,includingattorney'sfees,inanamounttobedeterminedbythecourt.   PlaintiffshallfileitsapplicationforsuchanawardonorbeforeNovember3,2003,and  DefendantshallfileanyobjectiononorbeforeNovember10,2003.    * January6,2004!  . xp   BYTHECOURT: PH _____________________________   DavidNuffer  U.S.MagistrateJudge